The medical paper has been developed in the last three hundreds of years into an instrument to communicate the outcomes of medical inquiry. Scientific writing will need to have of a standard that is high it really is related to the entire process of gaining knowledge when it comes to learned additionally as brand new learners. In ancient era, specific composing methodology ended up being used by the experts to organize standard and highly-scientific manuscripts within the field. Tools such as Tantrayukti (techniques for writing/decoding treatise), Tachchhilya (inclinations), Kalpana (compositions), etc., have now been described when you look at the classics to keep up the standard requirements of clinical literature. Because of writing that is well-established, medical literatures such as for instance Samhita (Ayurvedic texts), Samgraha–grantha (compendia), Nighantu (lexicons), etc., had been written uniformly and top quality literary works ended up being produced. The faculties of great medical writing for Shastra (treatise) have now been described within the Vimanasthana of Charaka Samhita that will be called Tantraguna. The Tantraguna covers one of the keys points associated with composing such as for example language, purchase, size, technique, etc. After reviewing and analyzing these Tantraguna, it may be determined that the writing that is ancient could be in contrast to some aspect to present introduction, practices, outcomes and conversation framework of clinical writing. This analysis may assist to enable and fortify the present requirements of clinical writing by modifying brand new facets of ancient writing method.
Keyword Phrases: Charaka Samhita, Tantraguna, Vimanasthana
|Simple tips to cite this informative article:|
Vyas HA, Panara K. Tantraguna – The ancient requirements for systematic writing. AYU 2016;37:158-62
| Simple tips to cite this URL:|
Vyas HA, Panara K. Tantraguna – The ancient requirements for medical writing. AYU serial online 2016 cited 2019 Aug 2;37:158-62. Offered by:
Composing is a really essential section of technology; it is utilized to report and communicate tips, tasks and findings to other people. Medical writing can just simply take numerous kinds from a laboratory notebook up to a project report and from the paper in a educational journal to a write-up in a magazine that is scientific. 1 Good writing requires the maximum amount of care and thought because the experiments or researches which can be completed. Composing a study paper or review article or text for medical technology isn’t a easy task. Nowadays, as scientific studies are needed for every industry of technology, its writing technique calls for uniformity with its presentation for clear interaction. Scientific documents must clearly be written and concisely in order that visitors with history much like the writer can comprehend effortlessly just what he’d done and exactly how he previously done. Presently, numerous recommendations are offered for systematic writing but introduction, techniques, outcomes and conversation (IMRAD) structure 2 is much more medical and popular in scientist community. While composing a study article, only facts should always be mentioned with proof which will be centered on careful observations. Nonetheless, in literary research, hypothetical writing might be permissible but once again it should be supported with strong and authentic traditional recommendations or very carefully gathered genuine big information. Construction, style, language, and general presentation of ideas will also be a few of the essential aspects to be viewed for writing a quality paper that is good.
In ancient era, literatures of numerous areas have now been written in Samskrit language. Further, similarity written down ways of texts of each and every industry suggested that uniform methodology that is writing used because of the ancient experts to prepare standard and highly-scientific manuscripts. Information on such methodology are located in Charaka Samhita, among the textbooks of ancient medical science. Composer of the writing, Acharya Charaka described composing methodology while describing the choice requirements for top-notch manuscript to a brand new scholar. 3 In this critical review, Tantraguna have now been put together from Charaka Samhita; further, it absolutely was interpreted and compared to current tools regarding the writing that is scientific.
TAG:2Tantraguna: The Characteristics Of Great Scientific Writing/TAG:2
Tantraguna have now been described in 8 chapter that is th of of Charaka Samhita. “Vimanasthana” section had been written when it comes to determination that is quantitative of certain attributes of treatment such as for instance Rasa, Dravya, Dosha and Vikara. 4 The eighth chapter of Vimanasthana relates to the dedication regarding the specific needs to treat conditions. 5 In the start of the chapter, scholars are encouraged for the choice of a typical medical text with good writing. To facilitate the choice, Acharya Charaka described the faculties of good medical writing which are elaborated as Tantraguna. Every single Tantraguna is furnished and interpreted the following.
Sumahat (well comprehensive)
Writing ought to be comprehensive. It will protect most of the necessary areas of the subject. right right Here, it’s also become taken into account that based on the structure of this article, size may be determined. In the amount of the manuscript, Vriddha Vagbhatta opines it should neither too long nor too quick. 6 This might be a criterion for research article or paper that is scientific or a novel; author should protect most of the aspects with crucial details.
Yashasvi-Dheera-Purusha-Sevita and Apta-pujita (accepted by medical fraternity)
Text which will be getting used by qualified, experienced individuals of this field that is same be viewed authentic. This characteristic suggests that the main topic of text ought to be popular in systematic community and its particular acceptability and applicability of real information in keeping training is high.
Arthabahulam (fine interpreted)
The writing should expose broad and accurate interpretations by a restricted quantity of words. The information regarding the topic should immensely be concise and significant. For structure of succinct and exact matter, ancient writers of Ayurveda utilized some methodology to facilitate simple transmission, similarly very theraputic for all. The definitions underlying the writing are to be interpreted with due regards towards the concepts of elaboration (Nirdesha) and decrease (Uddesha). 7
Trividha Shishya Buddhihitam (clearly expressed)
Literary concept of this particular feature is the fact that the treatise ought to be similarly suited to the understanding of three kinds of pupils, for example. very intelligent, low and moderate. What this means is that systematic paper should always be demonstrably expressed, effortlessly understandable and appealable to all or any forms of individuals associated with specific field i.e. from very intellectuals to normalcy.
Apagata Punarukta Dosha (no repetition of content or without plagiarism)
Medical writing must certanly be clear of repetition associated with topic. Thus, repetition of topic in exact same or various sentences in paper resulting in enhance associated with amount of pages is generally accepted as inferior of work. “Punarukta Dosha” might also suggest toward plagiarism. Utilizing other scientists’ a few ideas or any areas of their writing as the very own is just an offence that is serious as plagiarism. Therefore, Tantraguna additionally implies that information mentioned into the research really should not be copied from earlier in the day research works.
Learn should always be carried out and reviewed by impartial, genuine, and person that is scientific. Bias 8 may be raised from any conflict of great interest in experiments or by research carried out through nonscientific practices. Both types of bias trigger the generation of false and data that are unscientific. Ergo, scholar ought to be well designed with thorough familiarity with particular field and really should have no conflict.